Contact
Your law firm Geißler Legal.
address
Eupener Straße 59
D-50933 Cologne
Opening hours
Mon-Sat: 10:00 am – 1:00 pm
Mon-Fri: 2:00 pm – 8:00 pm
and by telephone appointment
Geissler Legal - Legal Advisor for Compliance & Commercial Law
New developments regarding conscription and conscientious objection - Legal assessment from a lawyer's perspective
Compliance-focused legal advice for your business activities - personal, cross-border, cost-efficient.
New developments regarding conscription and conscientious objection - Legal assessment from a lawyer's perspective
As a former conscientious objector and freedom-loving lawyer myself, I am following the political debate and the legal framework for the reintroduction of conscription in Germany very closely.
More and more clients – primarily young men of the affected age groups, but also their mothers and fathers – want to know: Who is affected? For whom does military service apply? At what age can one be drafted in Germany? Can I, if necessary, be selected from abroad by lottery?
At the same time, many are asking whether and how conscientious objection to military service is possible, especially in the case of short-notice legal reactivation or modification. This very point – the possibility of declaring conscientious objection in a timely and effective manner – is now central for many seeking advice. The debate surrounding conscription for women is also leading to a significantly increased need for counseling.
Contents
Constitutional foundations
Conscription is already fully enshrined in Article 12a of the Basic Law. The legislature can reintroduce compulsory military service by simply passing a conscription law, without the need for a state of defense or war.
For men, compulsory military service would be constitutionally permissible; however, according to Article 12a Paragraph 4 of the Basic Law, women are not permitted to perform armed service, although this does not mean that they could not be involved in other functions.
Possible design of a new conscription system
Should the reintroduction of conscription be decided upon, the process will likely be based on previous structures. These include, in particular:
- the central registration of potential conscripts,
- a mandatory military service questionnaire,
- medical examinations similar to the former conscription medical examination,
- Assignments by the German Armed Forces, the state, or a responsible federal agency such as the BAFzA,
- as well as organizational models such as a possible lottery procedure if more people are registered than needed.
A central point of the current political debate concerns the conscription age, or rather, the potential new conscription age. The current political proposals primarily focus on an age group between 18 and 30 years old. For many affected individuals, this leads to very real uncertainties: When could a conscription notice actually be issued? Does conscription in Germany begin on a fixed date or is it based on a specific birth year?
These questions are increasingly coming to the fore, as age limits significantly determine who may actually be called upon in the event of a statutory activation.
Conscientious objection as a fundamental right
Conscientious objection to military service is – as many are unaware – a fundamental right protected by Article 4, Paragraph 3 of the German Basic Law and therefore takes precedence over ordinary statutory regulations. This fundamental right applies directly and can only be limited by inherent constitutional constraints.
Anyone who wishes to refuse military service on grounds of conscience can submit an application for conscientious objection (KDV application). The forms – often available as a PDF application for conscientious objection or KDV application PDF – must be submitted to the Federal Office for Family Affairs and Civil Society (BAFzA).
The recognition process depends in particular on the following:
- a convincing personal justification, e.g. following the model of a justification example for conscientious objection to military service,
- a thorough examination by the responsible federal office,
- the comprehensibility and seriousness of the conscientious decision.
Our law firm assists clients with the formulation of applications, hearings, communication with the Bundeswehr career center, and appeal and legal proceedings – for example, when it comes to the recognition of refusal or official extradition and summons decisions.
Conscientious objection to military service in the event of defense or war
One of the most frequently asked questions concerns the situation in an emergency: Is conscientious objection to military service possible even in times of war? And can one refuse military service if an armed conflict or mobilization has already begun? We encounter this uncertainty regularly, as many clients fear that their rights could be restricted in a crisis or defense situation.
The clear legal answer is: Yes. The fundamental right applies without restriction, even in times of war or defense.
In practice, however, experience shows that applications are subject to more intensive scrutiny and that official deadlines are shorter. Legal representation is therefore particularly advisable.
Legal consequences of a refusal without application
Anyone who fails to comply with their legal obligations without having submitted a timely application for conscientious objection exposes themselves to considerable risks. These include, in particular:
- Fines or criminal penalties for failing to attend appointments at the career center,
- Omissions during the conscription process,
- as well as violations of official obligations to cooperate or extradition orders.
We provide early advice on all possibilities to avoid such consequences and ensure legally compliant behavior.
Alternative services and future models
Should political initiatives be implemented, civilian service could once again play a more significant role as an alternative to military service. This raises questions regarding exemptions, hardship provisions, and individual assignments. Our law firm assists clients in choosing suitable alternatives and enforcing their rights against government agencies.
Summary from a legal perspective
Our law firm provides comprehensive advice on all legal issues relating to conscription, military service in Germany, the introduction of conscription, the legislative process in the Bundestag, the rights of conscientious objectors, the enforcement of fundamental rights, and communication with the Bundeswehr, the Federal Office, and other authorities.
Our goal is to guide clients through all phases of legal proceedings in a legally secure manner – both in normal administrative procedures and in times of crisis.
Make an inquiry now
We will be happy to advise you comprehensively and personally on your concerns.
Attorney-at-Law (Germany, EU)
No posts found
English 
German 
Italian